When We Lost Our Heads
Quotes from the Book
We went out when we weren’t supposed to, we were too free, and this—all of this—is our punishment. It has nothing to do with the idea of us becoming dogs, and everything to do with the fact of us being girls.
Girls—normal human girls—people could contend with; they were weak and small. And dogs too could be trained. But girls who became dogs, or who let the world believe they were dogs, were either powerful or mad: both monstrous possibilities.
Lies could be told with such liberating ease—they tasted better on the tongue than hard facts.
Some of them were God-fearing, but their main god, the one at whose temple they worshipped most frequently, was violence. When they weren’t committing violent acts—brawling in the alehouse or beating their wives—violence seeped into their lives in other ways. It inflected their language. They often spoke of wounding and punishing, even killing. They wore their strength proudly, thumping fists on tables and slapping each other on the back.
Happiness was frail and flimsy: a petal, a whisper. Hardship was constant. It was muscular and loud. Only fools forgot this vital fact, her face explained. Only fools failed to let it guide their every waking thought and deed.
little tasks were the foot soldiers in the ongoing battle against despair.
thought. They turned a strong man weak. They made a good man penitent.
The looks the girls exchanged, the way they measured the distance to the bank with their eyes, was fortifying to him. He fed on it like a large meal. He deserved it, after the odd feeling they had given him, after they’d treated his polite enquiries with such contempt. He relished their fear. For a brief moment—no time at all, really—they were within his control.
It was for the six pregnant girls whom they made carry the coffin
Perhaps all the happier because he knew the feeling couldn’t last. It was a blooming flower at the height of summer: its time was now. Soon, it would wilt and shed and die, but for a brief moment it was beautiful.
That was what had frightened him the most: they were not mere doltish dogs, they were girls with teeth and claws. Girls had crazy whims and grudges—these ones especially. He didn’t trust them. They made him afraid.
All he wanted was some sign from them that they acknowledged him. That they saw him for what he knew himself to be: a man
They were angry. Perhaps not only about the sisters or the murdered man’s fate. They were angry about the weather and their failing crops and shallow wells
They were angry about the weather and their failing crops and shallow wells
The old thought returned to him, that he’d rather they were dogs than damaged girls. He’d rather they were free than confined by him.
She thought about what they all went through each day: the great, gruelling trial of being a woman in a world governed by men. How painful it was, and how humiliating. To be forced to hold your dead friend aloft because it was thought that you, in your smallness and stupidity, might not realise that this could be your fate. It made her tense and pale with rage.
In the shallow water, circling thick lily-pads, he found eyes and fidgeting forms - tadpoles turning into frogs. Some had stubby tails, others were dappled brown and green, caught in the border between different bodies.
For a moment, she wanted nothing but to think quietly about these women, and the many other women like them, and those unlike them too. She thought about what they went through each day: the great, gruelling trial of being a woman in a world governed by men. How painful it was, and how humiliating . To be forced to hold your dead friend aloft because it was thought that you, in your smallness and stupidity, might not realise that this could be your fate. It made her tense and pale with rage.
We went out when we weren't supposed to, we were too free, and this—all of this—is our punishment. It has nothing to do with the idea of us becoming dogs, and everything to do with the fact of us being girls. Girls—normal human girls—people could contend with; they were weak and small.
Girls — normal human girls — people could contend with; they were weak and small. And dogs too could be trained. But girls who became dogs, or who let the world believe they were dogs, were either powerful or mad: both monstrous possibilities.
The feeling was of triumph, and brilliance, and total, blissful possession. It felt like ruling and serving simultaneously.
Watch on YouTube
About Xenobe Purvis
About the book
The Crucible meets The Virgin Suicides in this haunting debut about five sisters in a small village in eighteenth century England whose neighbors are convinced they’re turning into dogs.
Even before the rumors about the Mansfield girls begin, Little Nettlebed is a village steeped in the uncanny, from strange creatures that wash up on the riverbed to portentous ravens gathering on the roofs of people about to die. But when the villagers start to hear barking, and one claims to see the Mansfield sisters transform before his very eyes, the allegations spark fascination and fear like nothing has before.
The truth is that though the inhabitants of Little Nettlebed have never much liked the Mansfield girls—a little odd, think some; a little high on themselves, perhaps—they’ve always had plenty to say about them. As the rotating perspectives of five villagers quickly make clear, now is no
Book details
- First published
- 2025
- Author
- Xenobe Purvis
- Genre
- Historical
- Goodreads rating
- 3.64 (23k ratings)
The buzz
- The New York TimesReview in The New York Timesprofessional review (via Book Marks)
- The Washington PostReview in The Washington Postprofessional review (via Book Marks)
- The AtlanticReview in The Atlanticprofessional review (via Book Marks)
- Publishers WeeklyReview in Publishers Weeklyprofessional review (via Book Marks)
- The SpectatorReview in The Spectatorprofessional review (via Book Marks)
- Star TribuneReview in Star Tribuneprofessional review (via Book Marks)
Keep reading
When We Lost Our Heads
Sleeping Beauties
The Prophets
The Devil and the Dark Water
The Quarry Girls
Glass Houses
The Children Act
Case Histories
Hunting Season
Tender Morsels
Gerald's Game
The Man Who Loved Children
The Naked and the Dead
Girls on Fire
The Benevolent Society of Ill-Mannered Ladies
When We Were Animals
The Children's Book
Little Heaven
The Poet Empress
The Story Sisters
The Last Mortal Bond
Down Cemetery Road
The Brutal Telling
Manhunt
Conjure Women
What It Means When a Man Falls from the Sky
Career of Evil
The Mermaid, the Witch, and the Sea
The Rose and the Beast: Fairy Tales Retold
The Invasion of the Tearling
The Damnation Game
The Bluest Eye
The Hidden Palace
The Little Friend
The Wayward Bus
The Burning Soul
The People of Sparks
The Cuckoo's Calling
The Liars' Club
Unholy Ghosts
A Rule Against Murder
Tar Baby
The Old Drift
All Out: The No-Longer-Secret Stories of Queer Teens throughout the Ages
Dubliners
The Guest
Transcription
Under the Skin
The Story of a New Name
Sister Carry
Woe to Live On
Regeneration
The Walls Around Us
Bastard Out of Carolina
The Red Garden
The Quick and the Dead
Sorrowland
Men We Reaped
Lives of Girls and Women
The Burgess Boys

