One of Us Is Lying
Quotes from the Book
Everybody has secrets,' she says, taking a sip of her drink. 'That's nondebatable. The only question is whether you're keeping your own, or someone else's.
Leave the past where it is
I thought you’d look how you talk.” I’m not going to rise to the bait and ask her what she means, but she keeps going without prompting. “Like a constipated gnome.
The loneliness of that settles over my shoulders like a heavy blanket.
You gotta shoot your shot when it comes...Who knows if you'll get another chance?
Do you mean proactive like when you fucked my swim coach and knocked her up? Is that the kind of proactive I should be shooting for?
Chloe likes the happy hour game because, she says, high school boys are immature. Which is true. But sometimes I think we might be better off not knowing how much worse they can get.
Jonah, I hear that you, Milly, and Aubrey are doing well, and I am glad. Truly. I bear you no ill will, and while I suppose it is fanciful to imagine that you and your “cousins” might reciprocate that sentiment, I hope it is the case. From one imposter to another, I’d like to give you some words of advice: keep your parents far away from Anders Story’s new venture. I have a strong suspicion that it will one day, as they say, go up in flames. Family first, always. P.
It’s a little weird, maybe, to be carting all this around, but I don’t know these people. And when I don’t know something, I study it.
Everybody has secrets,” she says, taking a sip of her drink. “That’s nondebatable. The only question is whether you’re keeping your own, or someone else’s.
It feels erratic ... But Alison knew what the problem was with her mother's heart: it was broken.
You have a very interesting look. Where are you from?' Ugh. That's marginally better than the What are you? question I get sometimes, but still gross. 'New York,' I say pointedly. 'You?' 'I mean originally,' he clarifies, and that's it. I'm done. 'New York,' I repeat, and stand up from my stool.
Anders turned, his eyes glittering in the moonlight. “Taking care of a problem.
Hey, Uncle Archer,” I say. My mother’s youngest brother’s eyes widen in alarm as I add, “Are you the one who brought us here?
The Story family is seriously messed up.
At first, all that registers is that this girl is drop-dead gorgeous. Dark hair, dark eyes, and full lips curved in a smirk that should probably be annoying but isn’t. She’s wearing a bright-red sundress and sandals, with sunglasses holding back her hair and a large, man-sized watch on one wrist, and—oh.
I think he might be an ex now,' I say as she zips up the back. 'My boyfriend, I mean.' 'You think?' 'Well, for awhile he wasn't returning any of my texts. Now I'm not returning his, so...' I trail off, and she finishes, 'That's how it's done nowadays, huh? Goodness, I feel for you kids. Life is so complicated in the digital age. But he doesn't sound like the catch you deserve. And--there!' She smooths her hands over my hips and beams. 'Look at you! Perfect!
Your polishing off an entire plate of shrimp linguine when you have a shellfish allergy is what tipped me off.
Typical last weekend in June,” my driver, Frederico, says as we crawl through Saturday-morning Cape Cod traffic. He brakes as the light we were about to pass through turns yellow. “What can you do, right?” I grit my teeth. “You could’ve run that light, for starters.” Frederico waves a hand. “Not worth it. Cops are everywhere today.
He has Draco Malfoy white-blond hair swept to one side, and he’s wearing a crisp white shirt and a tie patterned with bright-blue fish.
A job promotion, I decide. That must be it. Which is excellent news, except for the part where she’s going to remind me that she got it through hard work and oh, by the way, why can’t I work harder at literally everything.
A lie of omission is still a lie. You told a bunch of half-truths, and you let me think we were…friends….
It's been creeping up on me ever since I got to the island what my relationship with Thomas really is: something that should've ended a few months after it began in eighth grade, when he started treating me like an afterthought. But it didn't. Because there was something almost comfortable about that. I was used to it.
I can’t force you to leave the island, of course, but I hope that you do. This is my home, and you are not welcome here.
filing her nails. I listen to the receptionist answer an incoming call
this dress is the most perfect article of clothing I've ever worn - not only because it's beautiful and fits me like a dream, but also because it has deep pockets that hold a phone and some lipstick without ruining the line of the dress.
Did you know?
- The Cousins was a #1 New York Times bestseller and a USA Today bestseller.
- It was named an Amazon Best Young Adult Book of 2020 and a Barnes & Noble Best Young Adult Book of 2020.
- The novel was nominated for the 2021 Edgar Award for Best Young Adult mystery.
- The story is narrated through multiple alternating first-person perspectives plus a thread set in the parents' past.
- It was published by Delacorte Press on December 1, 2020.
About Karen M. McManus
More by Karen M. McManus
About the book
The Cousins is a young adult mystery thriller about Milly, Aubrey, and Jonah Story, three teenage cousins who barely know one another. Their wealthy, reclusive grandmother disinherited their parents decades ago with a single cryptic line, and the family has been estranged ever since. When the cousins each receive an unexpected invitation to spend the summer working at her exclusive island resort, their parents push them to go in hopes of repairing the rift. But once the cousins arrive on Gull Cove Island, it becomes clear their grandmother has very different plans for them, and the deeper they dig, the more they uncover about their family's buried secrets.
Told through alternating perspectives, the novel braids the cousins' present-day investigation together with a storyline set in their parents' youth, gradually revealing how the past shaped the present. McManus explores themes of family secrets, inherited wealth and its corrupting pull, identity, and the way long-held lies ripple across generations. The dual timeline structure builds suspense by letting readers piece together the truth alongside the characters.
The Cousins was a #1 New York Times bestseller and a USA Today bestseller, and was named an Amazon and Barnes & Noble Best Young Adult Book of 2020. It was nominated for the 2021 Edgar Award for Best Young Adult mystery, reflecting McManus's established reputation in the YA thriller genre following her bestselling debut One of Us Is Lying.
Key characters
- Milly StoryOne of the three cousins, sharp and image-conscious, daughter of one of the estranged Story siblings
- Aubrey StoryA cousin and competitive swimmer dealing with her parents' troubled marriage
- Jonah StoryThe lone grandson among the cousins, who is hiding a secret of his own
- Mildred StoryThe wealthy, reclusive grandmother who disinherited her children and summoned the cousins to the island
- Donald CamdenThe Story family lawyer tied to the original disinheritance
- TheresaThe grandmother's assistant on the island
Book details
- First published
- 2020
- Length
- 336 pages
- Reading time
- 4 hours
- Author
- Karen M. McManus
- Genre
- Mystery
- Goodreads rating
- 3.76 (150k ratings)
Critical reception
- Debuted as a #1 New York Times bestseller and a USA Today bestseller.
- Named a Best Young Adult Book of 2020 by both Amazon and Barnes & Noble.
- Nominated for the 2021 Edgar Award for Best Young Adult mystery.
If you liked this, read…
- 1One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManusMcManus's own breakout YA thriller with the same multi-narrator mystery structure
- 2We Were Liars by E. LockhartA wealthy family's dark secrets unravel during summers on a private island
Keep reading
Fated
Alex, Approximately
Going Vintage
The Summer I Became a Nerd
Time's Divide
The Boy Most Likely To
The Distance Between Us
Do Not Disturb
The Selection
My Lovely Wife
Suddenly Royal
A Touch of Jen
Unraveling Isobel
The Fine Art of Truth or Dare
When We Were Magic
Murder and Mamon
Cross My Heart and Hope to Spy
One of Us Is Lying
Fade
I've Got Your Number
One of Us Is Next
The Fixer
A Bend in the Road
Of Poseidon
The Descendants
The Nature of Jade
The Piper's Son
All Fall Down
Keep It in the Family
Saving Francesca
Family of Liars
Two-Way Street
The Curse of Tenth Grave
Save the Date
Never Date Your Brother's Best Friend
Twenties Girl
My Life Next Door
Omens
The Simple Wild
Not My Problem
The Coincidence of Callie & Kayden
Royally Screwed
Split Second
UnEnchanted
Demonglass
Banyan Moon
Supernaturally
Four Aunties and a Wedding
Girl Online
Holiday Romance
There You'll Find Me
A Match Made in High School
Bone Crossed
Shopaholic Ties the Knot
The Lightning Thief
A Little Wanting Song
The Year of Secret Assignments
Dark Companion
Greenwich Park
Letters to the Lost

