If He Had Been with Me
Quotes from the Book
She's made of the stories she has read.
My devotion to Autumn is engraved on my very being. I am in awe of her. I will sit in the stands and cheer her on in life as her most ardent admirer. I know I will always love her in the same way I know I'll always need oxygen.
If only I’d told her that I loved her years ago, I wouldn’t be here now.
it matters which people you spend time with, and it matters how you spend your time, because you don’t know how much you have.
It's all done. Finn's story is over. His whole life. That was it. Not even nineteen years, and he'll never, ever do anything else ever again. Finn won't go off to college or celebrate his birthday. He won't get another haircut or get the oil changed in his car. He won't bite a hangnail on his thumb or buy another CD. Finn Smith has done everything he will ever get to do. He won't get to be with Autumn.
I know I will always love her in the same way I know I'll always need oxygen.
I'll love her even if she turns out to be cruel. That's my curse.
This baby isn't what's left over from our love story. This baby is our story's continuation.
We’re just being close one last time.
We are all dead bodies that haven’t died yet.
Like, fairy-tale love? Cartoon character with hearts floating all around him? Or a movie montage with the best song? That's what you were to him. You were the biggest, most impossible dream for him.
Oh, Autumn.” My friend. My dream. My love.
Books are Autumn’s real life. She is made of the stories she has read.
If I had known. If I had only known. Things would have been different. That place still hurts. That place can't forgive.
My love for her is vehement, protracted, and interminable.
My love for her is the closest thing I have to religion. But it’s okay that she doesn’t feel the same. I’m fine. I can handle it.
There’re always things that we could have done differently. What matters is what we do now.
I'll go by the graveyard later and make sure he's settled in.
When you’re reading a book and you can’t focus, ask yourself, ‘How much is the writer’s fault, and how much is mine?’ Be honest. That’s how you’ll know if you should set it aside forever or for a few hours.
I’ve seen her finish a novel, pause staring off into space for a minute like she’s receiving instructions, and then open another book. It’s as if her job is to read and she’s behind on her quota.
Whatever our souls are made of, hers and mine are the same.
I've been thinking about Finn, and for the first time since Alexis's call that morning, it doesn't hurt. I'm so, so grateful that Finn was once alive and that I got to love him. That he got to love and be loved. And be loved still.
The reality is, what you imagined will never happen, and what you remembered is already done
I have to do it. It’s the last thing I’ll get to do for my friend ever again.
Time travel isn’t real, so it’s not a problem to solve.
The only way out is through.
But life is like that sometimes, and that’s a good thing.
All my agonies had been caused by figments of my imagination.
Whenever you and Finn Smith would see each other, at school or the mall or whatever, you guys would freeze for a split second. And then you would be moving and talking again, but it was like part of you was still frozen, waiting for the other person to do something.
With a plan in place, I climb out of the car and run across the rain-soaked pavement to her. I fall to my knees in front of Sylvie, putting my hand to the ground. It’s wet—
Did you know?
- It is a companion novel to Laura Nowlin's 2013 debut, If He Had Been with Me.
- The story is told from three alternating perspectives: Finn, Jack, and Autumn.
- Finn's sections take place in the days before his death, while Jack's and Autumn's unfold in the aftermath.
- It became a New York Times bestseller.
- Kirkus Reviews gave the book a 'Get it' verdict.
About Laura Nowlin
More by Laura Nowlin
If He Had Been with Me
About the book
If Only I Had Told Her is a young adult contemporary novel by Laura Nowlin, published in 2024 as a companion to her 2013 debut If He Had Been with Me. It retells and extends that story through three alternating points of view: Finn, in the days leading up to his death, as he finally reckons with his lifelong love for his best friend Autumn while dating Sylvie; Jack, Finn's grieving best friend, in the aftermath; and Autumn, navigating loss and her own mental health.
Built around unrequited love, friendship, and grief, the book dwells on the things left unsaid and the regret that follows sudden loss. It explores adolescent insecurity, miscommunication, fear-driven choices, and the long shadow a tragedy casts over the people left behind, carrying content warnings for its handling of death and mental health.
The novel was a New York Times bestseller and a Goodreads Choice Award nominee for Readers' Favorite Young Adult Fiction in 2024. It found a large audience among readers who had read the original, frequently recommended for fans of Colleen Hoover and Jenny Han, and Kirkus Reviews gave it a starred-style 'Get it' verdict while noting it lands hardest for those familiar with its predecessor.
Key characters
- FinnNarrator who has long been in love with his best friend Autumn while dating Sylvie
- AutumnFinn's lifelong friend and the object of his love, navigating grief and mental health
- JackFinn's best friend, who narrates the grief and anger after Finn's death
- SylvieFinn's girlfriend
Book details
- First published
- 2024
- Length
- 416 pages
- Series
- If He Had Been with Me #2
- Reading time
- 5 hours
- Author
- Laura Nowlin
- Genre
- Romance
- Goodreads rating
- 3.85 (210k ratings)
Critical reception
- A New York Times bestseller.
- Nominated for the 2024 Goodreads Choice Award for Readers' Favorite Young Adult Fiction.
- Kirkus Reviews gave a 'Get it' verdict, praising the well-written depiction of pain and anger while noting it resonates most with readers of the first book.
Series & reading order
- 1 If He Had Been with Me
- 2 If Only I Had Told Her
If you liked this, read…
- 1If He Had Been with MeThe original Laura Nowlin novel this book retells and continues
- 2It Ends with UsEmotional Colleen Hoover romance about love and loss, a frequent comparison
- 3They Both Die at the EndYA story centered on mortality, love, and the things left unsaid
Keep reading
Shades of Earth
Layla
Where One Goes
Far From You
Crossed
The Good Girl
My Name Is Memory
The Pact
Matched
First Love
Just for the Summer
If Tomorrow Doesn't Come
The Coincidence of Callie & Kayden
We Are Okay
The Siren
Dear John
Amelia Unabridged
Between the Lines
P.S. I Still Love You
A Walk to Remember
Fixing Delilah
The Gravity of Us
Blue Moon
The Wrong Daughter
One Day in December
More Than Forever
Aftermath
Losing Hope
Beautiful Chaos
The Gravity Between Us
Then She Was Gone
You've Reached Sam
Perfect Chemistry
The Smell of Other People's Houses
Light in the Shadows
The Edge of Never
The Love That Split the World
Kick, Push
Before Ever After
Wilder Girls
Lisey's Story
This Is How You Lose Her
The Time Traveler's Wife
The Revolution of Ivy
The Start of Me and You
The Universe of Us
Up in the Treehouse
The Way We Fall
The Pact
Beach Read
You Know Me Well
Believe Me
Butterfly Weeds
It Starts with Us
In This Moment
One
A Summer to Die
I Was Here
If He Had Been with Me
When the World Tips Over

